7 Morally Grey Romances in the ThriftBooks TropeTrove™

A dark retelling of the classic Peter Pan story, Emily McIntire’s Hooked tells a gripping tale of revenge and unexpected romance. James’s desire for revenge against Peter Michaels forces him to seduce the latter’s daughter, Wendy. But as James gets to know Wendy, his initial plans become tangled in a web of desire that challenges both his vengeance and his very nature. With a rating of 4.1, readers can find out why this story is captivating. Get your copy!

This unique friends-to-lovers dark comedy blends humor and romance within a thriller atmosphere. It tells the tale of Sloane and Rowan, two rival serial killers who bond over their shared penchant for mayhem. As they traverse a treacherous landscape filled with deadly games, their dark, thrilling friendship develops into a deeper connection, blurring the lines between love and chaos. With an impressive average rating of 4.3, this book is set to keep you laughing and gasping in suspense. Get your copy!

This captivating tale from Taylor Jenkins Reid chronicles the life of the iconic Hollywood star, Evelyn Hugo. As she opens up to journalist Monique Grant, readers are taken on a journey through love, loss, and the secrets of Old Hollywood. With a rating of 4.3, this novel’s rich exploration of female ambition and personal truths resonates strongly in a modern context. Read more about Evelyn's story!

I Penelope Douglas delivers a gripping dark romance that explores obsession and hidden desires. Erika, a college student, finds herself drawn to Michael, her boyfriend’s older brother, whose dangerous allure brings her nightmares to life. This standalone novel, with an average rating of 3.7, presents a twisted tale of vengeance and clandestine love that captivates with every turn of the page. Get your copy!

Kerrigan Byrne introduces readers to Dorian Blackwell, a dangerously charismatic antihero whose path collides with the spirited widow Farah Leigh Mackenzie. Their intense connection unfolds amidst betrayal and the realities of Victorian London, providing a thrilling narrative that captivates romance enthusiasts. Dorian's ruthless desire for revenge intertwines beautifully with a love story that ultimately reveals deeper truths. This compelling tale boasts a rating of 3.9. Explore this riveting read!

In the sequel to The Cruel Prince, Holly Black delivers an enthralling mix of political intrigue and romance. Jude finds herself entangled in the brooding complexities of her relationship with Cardan as she fights for control and survival in the treacherous world of Faerie. The suspense is palpable as Jude must contend with betrayals from those she trusts, all while grappling with her own feelings. Rated 4.2, this story intertwines power and passion in a beautifully fierce narrative. Read more about this captivating journey!

Chloe Neill introduces the humorous yet dangerous world of vampires in the first of the Chicagoland Vampires series. After being saved from an attack, Merit is turned into a vampire and thrust into a hidden society filled with unexpected surprises and adversities. As she navigates her new reality and unearths dark secrets, readers will enjoy a delightful mix of danger, romance, and wit. This novel has an average rating of 4.1, making it a must-read for fans of supernatural thrillers. Get your copy!